Best Buy’s Black Friday Fiasco: When Were Bosses Told?

Written by Evan Schuman
January 4th, 2012

Best Buy’s Black Friday disaster, when it took and confirmed Black Friday orders in November and then waited until a few days before Christmas to cancel those orders, is a huge deal precisely because it strikes at the very heart of E-Commerce fears. Namely, a consumer needs to feel confident that once an order is paid for, the product will absolutely be arriving shortly.

Although Best Buy has yet to spell out how this happened, the most likely scenario is that it was the so-called perfect storm of bad timing and possibly a quantity typo. Susan Busch, senior director of public relations at Best Buy, said many of the specific problems behind this incident are not yet clear, because the company is still working on its internal investigation. But what is known is that the problem involved a lot of people ordering some of the most deeply discounted Black Friday specials quickly and that “there was a delay” in processing to allow for the chain to “catch up on the orders.”

Many of those products were very limited, given the steep discounts. Best Buy’s suppliers, the manufacturers, “would only give us so many” at that price, Busch said.

Among the critical details that are not yet explicit are specific timing. When did Best Buy senior management understand the problem? How much of a delay happened while employees desperately tried to find the—unknown to them at that point—non-existent merchandise? In a $50 billion chain, news can travel upstream very slowly. When the news is bad, it travels upstream even more slowly.

That timing issue is essential. Had Best Buy learned of this sooner, it might have had time to work with manufacturers and have the purchased items delivered in time for Christmas. Worst-case scenario, it could have notified customers much sooner, giving them more time to replace the gifts.

The items at issue were popular electronics (games, cameras, laptops, etc.) and were highly discounted. Some have challenged the suggestion that Best Buy couldn’t get any more of those products, given that other chains were ordering and selling them, too. But the Best Buy orders reflected special discount arrangements with suppliers, so the shortage wasn’t about, for example, a PlayStation 3. It was about the very small number of PlayStation 3s that Best Buy’s supplier was willing to provide at that price.

(Related story: “Best Buy’s Black Friday Cancellations Were “Bait-and-Switch Breach Of Contracts”)

The next element is the nature of the Best Buy inventory system. The system enables some people to place in their carts more items than are available, on the assumption that not all cart purchases will be consummated. When enough of an item are actually purchased, then the system is supposed to remove that item from that which is available. Clearly, something glitched there.

One possible explanation is a typo in the quantity of the items the supplier was providing to Best Buy.


Comments are closed.


StorefrontBacktalk delivers the latest retail technology news & analysis. Join more than 17,000 retail IT leaders who subscribe to our free weekly email. Sign up today!
Our apologies. Due to legal and security copyright issues, we can't facilitate the printing of Premium Content. If you absolutely need a hard copy, please contact customer service.