The Perplexing Popcorn Payment Problem

Written by Evan Schuman
September 16th, 2006

The CIO of the nation’s largest movie theater chain struggles with how to push 500 popcorn-popping patrons through the refreshment stand before their movies start.

For David King, CIO of the $2.7 billion Regal Entertainment Group with theaters in 40 states, the challenge is a combination of arithmetic and consumer incentives. Beyond staggering movie start times and trying to get people to arrive earlier, King’s non-technology options are limited.

“We’ve tried many different strategies to try and encourage people to come to the movie more than around 20 minutes before the movie starts, but it really hasn’t moved needles. Everyone still comes around 20 minutes before the movie starts,” King said. “If the auditorium that is showing the movie holds 500 or 600 people, then 500 or 600 people need to go through the concession stand lines in 20 minutes. Once the time for the feature to start approaches, they will leave the lines and go back to their seats in order to watch the beginning of the movie as opposed to standing there and waiting in line to get their refreshments. It’s a matter of getting a huge mass of people through as quickly as possible in a short window of time.”

King is exploring various options, but is quickly coming to the same conclusion that the huge German grocery chain The Metro Group recently came to: the product-selection-and-distribution (for groceries, scanning) portion of a transaction must be physically separated from the payment part.

“I think it’s pretty significant. We have a major challenge with handling payments today,” King said. “Even at a concession stand where people are buying popcorn and Cokes and hot dogs–where there are very low levels of ticket quantities–people are using plastic, promotions, coupons, giftcards, loyalty cards, cash and a whole variety of other payment methods. That’s what is creating more of the holdup at our cash registers.”

King is exploring various tech options, including contactless payment credit cards, kiosks, at-home-prepay, lobby prepay and “anything to move the payment component of the transaction away from the actual delivery of the service or goods or tickets or food. We’re experimenting with several of those types of things, trying to get the customer experience correct and to satisfy the security guys and those types of people. It’s a major concern.”

The security concerns are those involving the recently-changed PCI requirements for credit card transactions and how to push those transactions through quickly, but still be fully compliant. Changes with wireless requirements in the new standard pose a particular hardship to a theater chain, where mobile payment stations could benefit from flexible wireless connections.

King discussed both the wireless dilemma and the payment separation challenge during last week’s Week In Review show here on StorefrontBacktalk. Please click here to see the show and please click here to just hear King and the other panelists discuss the payment separation challenge and please click here to listen to King and other panelists discuss the PCI and wireless changes.

Part of the problem is perception versus reality among consumers. Ironically, points out IDC Manufacturing Insights analyst Pete Abell, the perception issues plays doubly with the payment separation challenge.

In the beginning, Abell said, based on his experience making such a change at Chicago retailer several years ago, consumers resent the move because it’s creating two separate lines and consumers tend to assume that it will take them more time and be less convenient. But once they deployed, Abell said, everything flipped. Not only did the retailer enjoy a substantial time savings?through accelerated checkout lines?but consumers perceived the time savings for them as even greater than they were. “By separating the places, you definitely did speed up the consumer,” he said.

Beyond contactless payment, King said his chain had tried concession pods to try and disburse traffic. One unsuccessful effort involved creating express lanes, which were restricted to either those who phoned ahead or loyalty card members. What went wrong? The chain underestimated the anger of people in the other lanes, the ones who had to wait longer. As the movie start times approached, the regular line people got more upset and resentful.

“We created such animosity from the rest of the people who were standing in the other lines, it ended up being a bad situation and we weren’t able to solve how to deal with it,” King said. “This is for those who aren’t allowed to go through the express line, even if their movie is starting. Now they’re becoming grumpy. How do you manage through that scenario? We don’t have good solutions yet.”

Among some of the options is stealing some ideas from sports arenas. “We’re even going to be experimenting with some things that are ballpark-like where people will take orders in the auditoriums and have food and refreshments delivered to them,” King said. “In a variation on that, we’re looking at something called hawking, which is like the guys who walk up and down aisles in a ballpark with Cokes and a tray that has a strap around their neck and they sell Cokes out of the tray to the patrons.”

Some of the pre-payment options?such as having customers purchase both their tickets and pre-order and pay for their refreshments on a Web site?have typical restaurant challenges. How early should a hot dog be made so it will still be hot when eaten? Ice in beverages will melt and dilute a drink if it’s made too early. What about no-shows or customers who arrive late? During a snowstorm or other difficult weather, the number of noshows?or customers who make a last-minute request to see the movie at a different time?could be substantial.

Will the Saturday night movie become a 21st Century E-Commerce purchase merged with a 1950s era hot dog vendor walking the aisles before the movie starts and during intermission? What’s next? Bringing back drive-in movies but the films are digitally beamed in from satellites and are played on the car’s navigation screen?

The entertainment changes today are already threatening video-rental chains. I half-expect to see Blockbuster’s new TV commercials featuring the old lonely Maytag repairman. (“Come rent from us. We’re lonely. Nobody needs us anymore. Remember our old waiver of late fee campaign, the one where late fees were replaced with automatically charging your credit card for the full purchase price of the movie? We were just kidding. This time. we’ll really waive the late fees. Heck, we’ll waive all the fees if you just visit sometime.”)

It’s even hitting music, with Tower Records’ financial problems marking the likely beginning of the end of physical music stores.

This brings us back to the Regal challenge. (By the way, I would be remiss if I didn’t point out that having a chain called Regal with a CIO named King is a wonderful gift for writers everywhere.) Concession stands are, in theory, very simple retail operations, with very limited inventory. It’s merely the wide range of payment options that makes them complex, along with the very tight time window of a movie theater. If the concession stands could just take and fulfill orders, they could easily handle the onslaught. So moving payment away from purchase makes a lot of sense. But retrofitting a very old system and theater and conditioning people to act differently is difficult.

This is especially true when one looks at what a movie theater has become today. On the marketing diagrams, it is one of the most blatant examples of pure experience.

It will not be long before first-run movies will be easily available for a fee on every cellphone, cable system and satellite dish out there. Therefore, moviegoers are theaters will not be going solely for the film. It’s the experience of watching it with friends in a audience of hundreds of strangers, laughing, crying or getting scared at the same moments.

That means it’s going to all be about comfortable seats, top-quality audio and video systems (smell-aroma? Movement that is synched with what is going on in the film? How about appropriate temperature and other changes?) and superb customer service. In short, it needs to create an experience that a DVD player cannot recreate. King and his counterparts are right to be scared of long lines, cold hot dogs, watered-down soda and stale-tasting popcorn. In a business that will soon be 99.9 percent experience, even one bad payment experience can be devastating. Nowhere is a CIO’s role more critical.


6 Comments | Read The Perplexing Popcorn Payment Problem

  1. Chris Scott Says:

    In regards to the movie theater payment issue, it seems to me that many, if not most, would be happy to pay an extra three or four dollars at the ticket window and simply include the cost of food in the ticket price. Using a very simple RFID system, a ticket could be issued that gives the customer access to popcorn and drinks for a two hour period by simply swiping the ticket at a reader at the concession stand that lights green for good and red for bad. when the worker sees green, she hands over the food. If you didn’t want food, then you get a traditional paper ticket or a different RFID ticket and don’t pay the extra $4.00.

    Just my 2 cents.

  2. Dawne Marshall Says:

    You only need to eliminate half the line. Sell your Special movie tickets with Popcorn and Coke only. This can be part of the admission, or as a separate ticket (maybe even a discount for early purchase). When the customer shows their ticket as they enter to go to the movie, the popcorn and coke should be readily available. Anyone else will have to stand in line for hotdogs, candy, etc.

  3. David Thompson Says:

    You need to do what other movie theatre chains are now doing, changing to a service that allows you to sit down and watch the movie while you eat. Cinimaplexs are now putting tables into the theatres allowing a server to come and take your order. No lines, no hassle. I know, we have just installed one of our server notification systems into a cinimaplex allowing the servers to look at a LCD monitor showing the layout of each theatre and each person who is requesting service. The system even includes a manager pager, which will go off if some one is not serviced within reasonable time.

  4. John Franklin Says:

    I find it intereresting that movie theater concession stand can’t keep up with the flow of people.
    I have to ask, when have you seen more than 4 lines open on a busy night?
    Would it not make sense for the concession stands to be fully staffed? The Movie theater I go to is in Orland Park, IL and I’ve never seen it staffed more than 50% of capacity. They just don’t get it…Customer service is the #1 priority. I mean you have to give the customer some sort of value, i.e. good service. What you get at most theaters, are kids not caring and the theaters are charging more and more for tickets and candy.
    a box of dots costs around $0.58/ea and they charge $3.50/ea do the math!


  5. Frank Dekker Says:

    Thanks for another excellent story Evan. Most of the comments on this are spot on too. If Regal is intent on ‘selling’ popcorn, let them make sure they staff the counters properly, or indeed deliver to your seat. Somehow this all seems beside the point, though. As you so rightly point out, going to the movies is an experience and one poorly served by most movie theatres. The challenge is to create an environment in which customers feel they are part of the ‘movie-going-experience’. Food and drink distribution will follow as a logical consequence of the designed experience.


  6. Chuck Says:


    Fantastic story. I was at my local Regal (Chesapeake VA) last night and noted a few items during my Popcorn Transaction. My observation has been that the money transaction does not take as long as King might think. I have noticed (at this Theater) that there is “wasted motion.” Countless times, I have observed how far a CSR has to go just to fill your order. The Drinks are the quickest because the dispensers are typically next to the register. However, if they are only running one popcorn machine, the employee has to walk to the machine to fill the order. If you are going to a kids movie, expect delays due to the Kids Meal item. The kids meal is a drink, popcorn, candy and a box. The box is assembled at the time of order. These boxes could be pre-assembled (in the case where there is not a choice of candy, that could also be pre-packaged. During High Volume, the person taking the order should not be the person filling the whole order, just the drinks, make the payment (perhaps, if the counters were redesigned, the order would be done ala Burger King. You make your order, then you slide down several spots to receive your order). The Regal that I go to use to have dual concession stands that face each other. They have since closed it in (my guess is due to the lobby size and people queuing to get into their movie). And finally, they have a remote concession stand that, in the 10 years that I have been going to this theater, I have never seen used once.

    My “beef” with the Cinema industry really has to do with the pricing of the concessions. It only adds insult to injury that when we do get to the theater early, we have to watch a 20 minute pre-show chock full of advertisements – at that point we are a captured audience. But of course, I realize that concessions are the golden calf.

    Anyways, that’s my observations. Enjoyed your article!


StorefrontBacktalk delivers the latest retail technology news & analysis. Join more than 60,000 retail IT leaders who subscribe to our free weekly email. Sign up today!

Most Recent Comments

Why Did Gonzales Hackers Like European Cards So Much Better?

I am still unclear about the core point here-- why higher value of European cards. Supply and demand, yes, makes sense. But the fact that the cards were chip and pin (EMV) should make them less valuable because that demonstrably reduces the ability to use them fraudulently. Did the author mean that the chip and pin cards could be used in a country where EMV is not implemented--the US--and this mis-match make it easier to us them since the issuing banks may not have as robust anti-fraud controls as non-EMV banks because they assumed EMV would do the fraud prevention for them Read more...
Two possible reasons that I can think of and have seen in the past - 1) Cards issued by European banks when used online cross border don't usually support AVS checks. So, when a European card is used with a billing address that's in the US, an ecom merchant wouldn't necessarily know that the shipping zip code doesn't match the billing code. 2) Also, in offline chip countries the card determines whether or not a transaction is approved, not the issuer. In my experience, European issuers haven't developed the same checks on authorization requests as US issuers. So, these cards might be more valuable because they are more likely to get approved. Read more...
A smart card slot in terminals doesn't mean there is a reader or that the reader is activated. Then, activated reader or not, the U.S. processors don't have apps certified or ready to load into those terminals to accept and process smart card transactions just yet. Don't get your card(t) before the terminal (horse). Read more...
The marketplace does speak. More fraud capacity translates to higher value for the stolen data. Because nearly 100% of all US transactions are authorized online in real time, we have less fraud regardless of whether the card is Magstripe only or chip and PIn. Hence, $10 prices for US cards vs $25 for the European counterparts. Read more...
@David True. The European cards have both an EMV chip AND a mag stripe. Europeans may generally use the chip for their transactions, but the insecure stripe remains vulnerable to skimming, whether it be from a false front on an ATM or a dishonest waiter with a handheld skimmer. If their stripe is skimmed, the track data can still be cloned and used fraudulently in the United States. If European banks only detect fraud from 9-5 GMT, that might explain why American criminals prefer them over American bank issued cards, who have fraud detection in place 24x7. Read more...

Our apologies. Due to legal and security copyright issues, we can't facilitate the printing of Premium Content. If you absolutely need a hard copy, please contact customer service.