Evan Schuman's StorefrontBacktalk

To be specific, Wall Street doesn't think that all IT investments are cool. It's when IT investments come from companies where it's not expected. When eBay or, heaven forbid, Amazon invest in IT, Wall Street lets them have it with both spreadsheets, in a way that it would have never criticized Wal-Mart for opening new stores. But when the Sears and Macy's of the world start talking about these space-age computer thingies, stock analysts get all starry-eyed.Read more...

For readers focused on any of those areas, the Monthlies provide an easy way to keep up-to-date and to make sure you don't miss any story important to your operation. The Monthlies also have two other helpful features.Read more...

The idea behind P2PE, pens PCI Columnist Walter Conway, is that an encrypting POS terminal encrypts the cardholder data (the first "point") immediately as the customer's card is swiped. A third-party service provider (the second "point," and often the merchant's card processor) manages both encryption and key management. The third party is the only one that can access the actual cardholder data. The result is that when P2PE is properly implemented, almost all the merchant's systems are out of PCI scope because the merchant has no way to decrypt the data or ever to get access to the clear-text cardholder data. Read more...

There are two different legal precedents for these situations, writes Legal Columnist Mark Rasch—and in fact, they go in exactly opposite directions. That creates an inherent problem, for both consumer relations and the law. Customers could feel cheated if price changes don't work the way the customer expects. And as ESLs make in-store pricing work more like online pricing, that could change the way courts see it.Read more...

That sounds just a wee bit hypocritical, especially because Wal-Mart is unquestionably required to collect sales taxes online given that it has both brick-and-mortar stores and an E-Commerce distribution center in California. But the problem—and Wal-Mart's excuse—points out a legitimate issue when it comes to collecting those taxes online. A traditional store's boundaries are pretty straightforward. But online, it can get a lot harder to tell where one retailer ends and another begins, and exactly who is supposed to be collecting which taxes.Read more...

The deal also effectively signals an end to a string of political and court battles in New York, Illinois, Connecticut, Rhode Island, North Carolina, Arkansas and Colorado. Amazon—which California calculated would be responsible for delivering half the online sales taxes the state expects to collect—is now in a race to get Congress to authorize online sales taxes. And unless the rest of the pure-play E-tailers decide to fight it, Amazon will drag them all along in its slipstream.Read more...

Although you got a telephone number and directions, Google got information about not only what people in general were searching for (people in Piscataway picked pizza) but also what a specific person was looking for (John Smith—or John's telephone—searched for the number for an AIDS clinic, then a drug store, then life insurance). Again, because Google isn't a phone company or particularly regulated in any way, it could use or sell this information in any way consistent with whatever privacy policy it wrote. But Google got much more than that. Read more...

Dollar General on Thursday (Sept. 8) will launch its first-ever E-Commerce site. It’s not clear why the $13 billion chain hadn’t gone to Web sales some 16 years ago, although Dollar General “waiting to see if this E-Commerce thing isn’t a passing fad” can’t be ruled out. The chain is starting small, with initial plans to offer only 1,000 SKUs, less than one-tenth of the 12,000 SKUs that the 9,500-store chain’s typical locations offer. There are no official plans for in-store-pickup, with shipments the only initial distribution method.

CEO Rick Dreiling told an investor conference call that the E-Commerce site was for “customers who, like many of you, may not have a convenient Dollar General. We plan to sell single items as you would find in our stores as well as larger quantities that we stock in our stores. And from time-to-time, we’ll also feature limited quantities of special buys.” When asked to quantify what he expects the E-Commerce site to do in terms of revenue, the CEO asked for more time to answer. “What I’d rather do is give you an update on that when it has been up and running for a while. This is brand new for us. We do know that there has been request for it. We do know there is demand for it, but I just don’t know enough yet about how it’s going to go, what it’s going to generate.”…

It's not just that the new homepage is cleaner and more open to make it easier to browse (and buy) from a tablet. The same changes—bigger buttons, less clutter and small print—will make the site much friendlier to other customers, too. That could force other E-tailers to throw out the rulebooks for their own aging Web site designs—most of which probably seemed like a good idea in 1995, but haven't been completely revamped since E-Commerce became serious business a decade ago.Read more...

Although there are lots of factors at play here, the primary power benefit of mobile is its battery power supply and, to be quite cold about it, the fact that the customer's device is powered by the customer. The power benefit of M-Commerce is that its power supply is probably a long distance away, somewhere not impacted by whatever is causing a store's power outage.Read more...

Why? What went wrong? Actually, not much, from the point of view of experienced developers. Naturally the site had glitches—that's to be expected. And Target's plan of starting with a new site that had the same basic functionality as the old site, and only later rolling out exciting new features supported by what's baked into the new architecture, was a solid development approach. Unfortunately, although that plan worked very well for developers, it made no sense at all to customers—the people any E-Commerce site is supposed to be all about.Read more...

The dream—and nightmare—of every E-Commerce head is to start over from scratch, scrap all the legacy kludges that developers have been working around for years and build a Web site that does exactly what the chain wants. Most retailers will never be able to cost-justify that greenfield approach, of course. Target's site, however, had to be built from scratch because its decade-long deal with Amazon to operate its online business had expired.Read more...

Indeed, the associate might have gotten away with it, had he not gotten too greedy and obvious. How obvious? He purchased the chain's most expensive Movado watch—a $2,995 Swiss timepiece with a tungsten carbide bracelet—but not before he "processed an unauthorized markdown" to make the price $2.95. Think a better-than 99.9 percent discount would trigger a flag? The good news for Macy's low prevention: It did indeed trigger a flag. The bad news: Nothing in the system stopped the associate, who had worked for Macy's less than five months at the time, from processing it and having the product shipped.Read more...

PCI compliance doesn't come in grades and is a very clean pass-fail situation. That's why the vendor's headline caught our eyes: "Transaction Wireless First Cloud-Based Digital Giftcard Platform to Earn Highest PCI Level 1 Certification." That is a truly delightful piece of sleight of hand.Read more...

Suppose a customer's phone contains a shopping list of specific apparel items she wants to buy from another retailer—including images of those items or even links to them on the retailer's Web site. A shared screen could make it very easy for an associate to suggest alternatives or help the customer mix and match, whether the items are in the store or not.Read more...

A recent credible survey, however, found that not only are most younger consumers oblivious to what QR codes are, but the many who do know what they are can't get them to function. In short, 83 percent of the 1,300 14- to 24-year-olds surveyed couldn't access a QR code regardless of how good the offer was. Looks like some people skipped an important step in product rollout. That news is pretty bad, given the strong mobile interest—or general high-tech and experimentation comfort level—of that demographic. If they're confused or apathetic, the numbers won't likely get better as surveys examine consumers in their 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s and beyond.Read more...

"No one has cracked the code on how social media impacts retail. I recently had an agency pitch an app as a way to build brand awareness. I pointed out that for someone to go to the trouble of downloading an app, they already need to be aware of the brand. So at best you could argue that it would help brand engagement, but not brand awareness. Lots of money is being spent in this area. Suspect most of it is being poured down a rat hole." The rat hole is simply that retailers don't have the ability today to understand the social-media influence on retail, and that lack of understanding is almost certainly causing a lot of wasted effort and money.Read more...

The token guidance that the group and the PCI Council staff ultimately released on August 12 was a classic compromise, in that it pleased few in the group but was a huge step forward for retail security. The purpose of such guidelines is not to get so specific that it benefits any vendor, but to give instructions to QSAs and retailers on what is permissible and what isn't. Reaction to the document has fallen into these two camps: one saying that the document was not nearly specific enough and is passing the buck to QSAs, and the other saying that this guidance represents major progress and that it should be applauded.Read more...

PCI Columnist Walter Conway thought a token was a token. Whether a particular token, or tokenization approach, was in or out of PCI scope seemed to depend on how well it was constructed and how the tokenization engine and token vault were implemented. But it seems that some tokens are more equal than others. For example, E-Commerce merchants who use tokens for one-click ordering and repeat purchases (leaving the underlying primary account numbers with their processor or another third party) just learned their tokens will still be in scope for PCI. Wonder if that hotel room keycard (or resort account) used to charge meals is a high-value token because it generates a payment-card transaction? How about the tokens used for exception-item-processing such as chargebacks and refunds. Are they high-value tokens because they impact (even if it is to reverse) transactions?Read more...

Granted, there are shopping carts full of complexities and nuances in analyzing such profiles—generating a meaningful influence rate, if you will—but that's where the fun comes in. Even worse, beyond those analytical complexities, there's the issue of how to get this data in front of the eyes of store associates and also how to do it in a timely matter. Of course, to start things off, there needs to be a reliable way to identify these influencers as they enter your store.Read more...

Let's take this slowly. Circuit City hasn't been an in-store national chain since 2009. But when it liquidated, no one apparently thought about the IP addresses, according to Gabe Fried, the founding principal of Stream Bank LLC, which handled Circuit City's liquidation and is now handling the one for Borders. "The people who knew that [Circuit City] had these assets left the company" rather abruptly when Circuit City didn't find a buyer for the chain and liquidation proceedings began, Fried said. "The problem involved management bandwidth and a lack of knowledge of [the IPv4 addresses'] existence."Read more...

When Wal-Mart confirmed a major E-Commerce reorganization on August 12—including the loss of Walmart.com chief Steve Nave and global E-Commerce exec Raul Vazquez—it was said that E-Commerce management in developed countries will now report to the senior in-store executive for each country. That’s a change from those positions reporting into Global E-Commerce boss Eduardo Castro-Wright. If we set aside the personnel issues—the loss of execs such as Nave will likely hit hard—the strategy involved here is both compelling and actually the right approach.

One of the most vexing merged-channel issues today is how to compensate online and in-store execs so they don’t solely push their primary channel. By having the chief of Wal-Mart’s U.S. stores, for example, also responsible for Walmart.com sales in the U.S., that compensation/conflict-of-interest issue goes away. Well, it theoretically could go away, assuming the U.S. president makes sure the compensation of various direct reports is similarly merged. The ideal here is for everyone to be focused on selling Wal-Mart products however they can, with no financial incentive to push mobile, online, in-store, call center or any other specific channel. To the extent that this reorg helps bring the chain closer to that goal, it’s a good thing.…

Leach added that the biggest token-related mistake he's seen retailers make is enabling the data to be de-tokenized during chargebacks, refunds or for loyalty tracking. "That's probably the oversight we see most often: not recognizing back channels where the merchant still may receive that account information."Read more...

Visa's new approach will also likely spell the end—within about five-to-seven years—of mag-stripe cards in the U.S., a move that many payment security advocates say is years overdue. To make all of this happen, Visa is bringing its global EMV incentive program—officially the Technology Innovation Program (TIP)—to the States, along with its PCI-relaxation components. (PCI relaxation? There are two words I never expected to see used consecutively.) This means chains that start using specific EMV chip-enabled terminals will be permitted to forego the annual compliance validation nightmare. But Visa has added such a lengthy list of qualifiers and exceptions to the program—along with the practical fact that some chains will opt to do the assessments anyway, for pure security purposes—that it's not clear how many chains will find that incentive compelling enough to do massive hardware swaps.Read more...

Nohl told The New York Times that mobile operators turn off GPRS encryption "to be able to monitor traffic, to detect and suppress Skype, or to filter viruses, in a decentralized fashion." Unfortunately, that also means thieves with reprogrammed mobile phones can eavesdrop on many M-Commerce transactions using GSM smartphones. And even if payment-card information gets its own layer of encryption, there's still plenty of other personal data that customers would probably prefer not to fall into the hands of thieves.Read more...